PrepZen Daily Current Affairs & Exam Desk
Editorial · 2 min read · THE HINDU PAPER EDITORIAL

Textbook Tangle: When Judiciary and Executive Overlap

Share: WhatsApp
Recent events have cast a spotlight on the sensitive relationship between educational content and the perceived integrity of state institutions. A Supreme Court bench recently reacted strongly to criticisms of the judiciary found in an NCERT Class 8 social science textbook. The Court characterized these references, which touched upon judicial pendency and alleged corruption, as a 'deep-seated conspiracy,' asserting its resolve to protect the judiciary's reputation . Following this, the Education Minister expressed regret and pledged action against officials deemed responsible for their inclusion. Critics argue that this response from the executive might represent an act of arbitrariness , prompted by what some perceive as judicial overreach . While courts typically tolerate critical discourse , the official nature of textbooks often accords them a unique authority, leading to heightened scrutiny . Indeed, instances of judicial malfeasance are not unheard of, and attempting to censor educational material is unlikely to serve as a genuine corrective . The ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) has consistently prioritized the revisiting of school and college curricula since assuming power. This agenda often emanates from a viewpoint that views certain judicial rulings—especially those favoring environmental concerns over development, or religious practices—as detrimental to national interests. Some passages in the textbook were undeniably unrefined , resembling sweeping social media pronouncements rather than meticulously researched academic assertions . For instance, the text stated that "People do experience corruption at various levels of the judiciary." However, similar critical portrayals were also directed at the government and the political executive, suggesting an intent to foster critical awareness rather than peddle bias . Nevertheless, the curriculum includes other contentious sections. History chapters often valorize medieval Hindu kingdoms, depicting their struggles as legitimate resistance against Muslim rule, while downplaying the complexities of warfare driven by plunder and territorial aggrandizement . Conversely , Muslim kingdoms are often presented negatively, with only fleeting mentions of figures like Akbar's tolerance or Babur's intellectual pursuits. The imbalance is further compounded by contrasting portrayals of Mughal-era wealth and colonial penury . The core issue isn't that the textbook singles out the judiciary, but rather that institutions sensitive to criticism take issue with specific passages. A truly unbiased and comprehensive educational framework is imperative for nurturing informed citizens.

Get daily updates on PrepZen App

Free · 10,000+ downloads · 4.8★

Download

Vocabulary from this Editorial

Accords verb

To grant or give (power, status, or recognition) to someone or something.

Synonyms: grants, bestows, confers

"The committee <b>accords</b> high priority to environmental protection in its recommendations."

Agenda noun

A list of items to be discussed at a formal meeting; a plan of things to be done.

Synonyms: program, plan, schedule

"The government's economic <b>agenda</b> focuses on job creation and industrial growth."

Aggrandizement noun

The act of increasing the power, status, or wealth of a person or organization.

Synonyms: exaltation, elevation, magnification

"His ruthless pursuit of territorial <b>aggrandizement</b> led to numerous conflicts."

Alleged adjective

Stated without proof; supposed.

Synonyms: claimed, purported, unproven

"The police are investigating the <b>alleged</b> theft of valuable artifacts from the museum."

Arbitrariness noun

The quality of being based on random choice or personal whim, rather than any reason or system.

Synonyms: capriciousness, whimsicality, randomness

"The sudden changes in policy reflected the <b>arbitrariness</b> of the new leadership."

Assertions noun

Confident and forceful statements of fact or belief.

Synonyms: claims, declarations, statements

"The report contained several unsupported <b>assertions</b> that lacked factual evidence."

Bias noun

Prejudice in favor of or against one thing, person, or group compared with another, usually in a way considered to be unfair.

Synonyms: prejudice, partiality, favoritism

"Journalists should strive to report news without any personal <b>bias</b>."

Censor verb

To examine (a book, movie, etc.) officially and suppress unacceptable parts of it.

Synonyms: expurgate, redact, bowdlerize

"The authorities decided to <b>censor</b> several scenes from the film before its release."

Characterized verb

Described the distinctive nature or features of.

Synonyms: described, defined, identified

"The region's economy is <b>characterized</b> by a strong agricultural sector."

Complexities noun

The intricate or complicated parts of something.

Synonyms: intricacies, complications, difficulties

"Understanding the <b>complexities</b> of quantum physics requires deep study."

Comprehensive adjective

Including or dealing with all or nearly all elements or aspects of something.

Synonyms: inclusive, thorough, extensive

"The new policy provides a <b>comprehensive</b> approach to tackle unemployment."

Compounded verb

Made (something bad) worse; intensified the negative aspects of.

Synonyms: aggravated, exacerbated, intensified

"The economic crisis was <b>compounded</b> by a series of natural disasters."

Consistently adverb

In every case or on every occasion; invariably.

Synonyms: steadily, uniformly, regularly

"She has <b>consistently</b> demonstrated excellent performance in her academic pursuits."

Contentious adjective

Causing or likely to cause an argument; controversial.

Synonyms: controversial, disputable, debatable

"The issue of climate change remains a highly <b>contentious</b> topic in international politics."

Conversely adverb

Introducing a statement or idea that reverses one that has just been made or referred to.

Synonyms: on the contrary, conversely, alternatively

"Some studies suggest that increased screen time is harmful for children; <b>conversely</b>, others highlight its educational benefits."

Corrective adjective

Intended to correct or improve something.

Synonyms: remedial, ameliorative, reparative

"The manager implemented <b>corrective</b> measures to address the team's declining productivity."

Depicting verb

Representing (someone or something) in a work of art or literature; portraying.

Synonyms: portraying, illustrating, representing

"The artist is known for <b>depicting</b> vibrant scenes of everyday life in the city."

Detrimental adjective

Tending to cause harm; harmful.

Synonyms: harmful, damaging, prejudicial

"Lack of proper sleep can be <b>detrimental</b> to one's overall health and concentration."

Discourse noun

Written or spoken communication or debate.

Synonyms: conversation, discussion, dialogue

"Academic <b>discourse</b> requires rigorous research and logical argumentation."

Emanates verb

(Of a feeling, idea, or smell) issues or spreads out from (a source).

Synonyms: originates, springs, arises

"A strong sense of calm <b>emanates</b> from the meditation center."

Fleeting adjective

Lasting for a very short time.

Synonyms: brief, transient, momentary

"The joy of victory was <b>fleeting</b>, as the team had another tough match ahead."

Foster verb

Encourage or promote the development of (something good, typically something regarded as desirable).

Synonyms: promote, encourage, nurture

"The school aims to <b>foster</b> a love of learning among its students."

Heightened adjective

Made more intense or acute.

Synonyms: intensified, increased, amplified

"The political tensions led to a <b>heightened</b> sense of anxiety among the citizens."

Imbalance noun

A lack of proportion or relation between corresponding things.

Synonyms: disproportion, asymmetry, inequality

"An <b>imbalance</b> in trade can lead to economic instability."

Imperative adjective

Of vital importance; crucial.

Synonyms: crucial, vital, essential

"It is <b>imperative</b> that all safety regulations are strictly followed."

Integrity noun

The quality of being honest and having strong moral principles; moral uprightness.

Synonyms: honesty, sincerity, morality

"The judge was praised for his unwavering <b>integrity</b> throughout his career."

Legitimate adjective

Conforming to the law or to rules; lawful.

Synonyms: lawful, legal, valid

"The court ruled that the claim was <b>legitimate</b> and ordered compensation."

Malfeasance noun

Wrongdoing, especially by a public official.

Synonyms: misconduct, wrongdoing, impropriety

"The mayor resigned amidst allegations of financial <b>malfeasance</b>."

Meticulously adverb

In a way that shows great attention to detail; very carefully and precisely.

Synonyms: carefully, precisely, thoroughly

"The artisan <b>meticulously</b> crafted each piece of jewelry by hand."

Nurturing verb

Caring for and protecting someone or something while they are growing or developing.

Synonyms: fostering, cultivating, cherishing

"The teacher's role is crucial in <b>nurturing</b> young minds and talents."

Overreach noun

The act of going beyond proper or reasonable limits.

Synonyms: exceeding, transgression, overstepping

"Critics argued that the executive order was an act of governmental <b>overreach</b>."

Peddle verb

To try to sell (something, especially an illegal or unauthorized item); to promote (an idea or view) persistently.

Synonyms: promote, advocate, push

"The politician was accused of trying to <b>peddle</b> false information to the public."

Pendency noun

The state of being pending or awaiting settlement.

Synonyms: unresolvedness, waiting, incompleteness

"The high <b>pendency</b> of cases in courts is a major concern for the judiciary."

Penury noun

The state of being extremely poor; poverty.

Synonyms: poverty, destitution, indigence

"Many families were reduced to <b>penury</b> during the economic depression."

Pledged verb

Committed (a person or organization) by a solemn promise.

Synonyms: promised, vowed, guaranteed

"The charity organization <b>pledged</b> to provide assistance to the flood victims."

Plunder noun

The violent and dishonest acquisition of property.

Synonyms: loot, booty, spoils

"Historical accounts describe the immense <b>plunder</b> taken by the invading army."

Portrayals noun

Descriptions or representations of someone or something.

Synonyms: depictions, representations, renderings

"The film offered accurate <b>portrayals</b> of life in rural India."

Prioritized verb

Designated or treated (something) as more important than other things.

Synonyms: ranked, focused on, favored

"The company <b>prioritized</b> customer satisfaction above all other objectives."

Prompted verb

Caused or brought about (an action or feeling).

Synonyms: instigated, triggered, incited

"The sudden noise <b>prompted</b> an immediate reaction from the audience."

Reputation noun

The beliefs or opinions that are generally held about someone or something.

Synonyms: standing, fame, status

"The company has built a strong <b>reputation</b> for quality and innovation."

Resolve noun

Firm determination to do something.

Synonyms: determination, steadfastness, purpose

"Her unwavering <b>resolve</b> helped her overcome numerous obstacles to achieve her goals."

Revisiting verb

Considering or discussing (something) again, especially after a period of time.

Synonyms: reconsidering, re-examining, reappraising

"The committee is <b>revisiting</b> the old policies to update them according to current needs."

Scrutiny noun

Critical observation or examination.

Synonyms: examination, inspection, analysis

"Every detail of the project underwent intense <b>scrutiny</b> before approval."

Sweeping adjective

Extending over a large area or range; wide-ranging.

Synonyms: extensive, broad, comprehensive

"The politician made <b>sweeping</b> promises that were difficult to fulfill."

Unbiased adjective

Showing no prejudice for or against something; impartial.

Synonyms: impartial, neutral, objective

"A judge must remain <b>unbiased</b> to ensure justice is served fairly."

Unrefined adjective

(Of a substance) not processed or purified; crude; (of a person or their behavior) not elegant or cultured.

Synonyms: crude, rough, coarse

"His initial drafts were often <b>unrefined</b>, but he would polish them into brilliant essays."

Valorize verb

Give value or validity to (something); enhance the status of (something) by presenting it as important or useful.

Synonyms: exalt, glorify, celebrate

"The museum seeks to <b>valorize</b> the contributions of local artists."

Viewpoint noun

A person's opinion or point of view.

Synonyms: perspective, stance, opinion

"It's important to consider different <b>viewpoint</b>s before making a decision."

Phrasal Verbs

cast a spotlight on

To draw public attention to something.

"The recent scandal <b>cast a spotlight on</b> the need for stricter financial regulations."

touched upon

Mentioned or referred to briefly.

"The speaker <b>touched upon</b> several key issues during her brief address."

downplaying

Making something seem less important than it actually is.

"The politician was accused of <b>downplaying</b> the severity of the economic crisis."

singles out

Chooses one person or thing from a group for special attention or treatment.

"The teacher often <b>singles out</b> diligent students for praise."

take issue with

To disagree with someone or something; to challenge or dispute.

"I must <b>take issue with</b> your assertion that the project is behind schedule."

PrepZen

Keep Learning with PrepZen

Get daily current affairs, live mock tests, mistake bank, vocab builder & more — all free on your phone.

Download Now — Free
PrepZen

Get PrepZen Free

Daily CA, Mock Tests & More

GET