PrepZen Daily Current Affairs & Exam Desk
Editorial · 2 min read · THE HINDU PAPER EDITORIAL

The Judiciary and the Imperative of Scrutiny

Share: WhatsApp
The delicate balance between judicial authority and public scrutiny has become a subject of intense debate, particularly in the context of contemptuous behavior. While courts possess the inherent prerogative to penalize actions that undermine their dignity, the consistency with which they draw lines between legitimate critique and overly exaggerated commentary has been highly variable . The judiciary frequently struggles to make out clear boundaries, often blurring the lines between warranted criticism and politically charged statements. This ambiguity is exacerbated by a landscape rife with misinformation, intense political pressure, and a growing tide of online abuse, all of which contribute to a perceptible decline in public trust.Recent pronouncements from the Bench have unfortunately fostered an impression of increased judicial intolerance towards external examination. For instance, the Chief Justice of India recently employed unbecoming epithets , labeling certain legal professionals as "parasites" and young RTI activists as "cockroaches." Although these remarks were later clarified, such incendiary language from the highest judicial office creates a deterrent effect, amounting to institutional condemnation without due process. Similar concerns cropped up from the Supreme Court's manifest ire directed at academics involved in an NCERT textbook, effectively marginalizing them without proper hearing. The Court's response to a journalist seeking data on judicial complaints, brushing off it as a "fishing and roving" inquiry, further exemplifies this defensive posture , raising questions about the judiciary acting as both the aggrieved party and the arbiter . These incidents call into question the judiciary's commitment to transparency.Such incidents stand in stark contrast to the perspective put forth by former CJI D.Y. Chandrachud, who emphasized that judges, as public functionaries wielding state power, should not succumb to a defensive posture against every line of criticism. That more accommodating attitude had previously ameliorated interactions among the bar, the press, and the academy. Regrettably, the recent shift in judicial temperament appears to reverse these positive developments, signaling a potentially retrogressive phase for judicial openness and accountability . The critical examination of judicial conduct is not an act of subversion but a cornerstone of a healthy democracy.

Get daily updates on PrepZen App

Free · 10,000+ downloads · 4.8★

Download

Vocabulary from this Editorial

Accountability noun

The fact or condition of being accountable; responsibility.

Synonyms: Responsibility, Liability, Answerability

"Government officials must maintain a high level of <b>accountability</b> for their actions."

Accommodating adjective

Willing to fit in with someone's wishes or needs; helpful.

Synonyms: Obliging, Compliant, Cooperative

"The hotel staff were very <b>accommodating</b> to our special requests."

Ameliorated verb

Made something bad or unsatisfactory better.

Synonyms: Improved, Alleviated, Mitigated

"The new policies have significantly <b>ameliorated</b> working conditions for employees."

Ambiguity noun

The quality of being open to more than one interpretation; inexactness.

Synonyms: Uncertainty, Vagueness, Equivocation

"The <b>ambiguity</b> in the law made it difficult for citizens to understand their rights."

Arbiter noun

A person who settles a dispute or has ultimate authority in a matter.

Synonyms: Judge, Umpire, Mediator

"The Supreme Court acts as the final <b>arbiter</b> in constitutional matters."

Blurring verb

Making or becoming unclear or less distinct.

Synonyms: Obscuring, Fuzzing, Dimming

"The boundaries between work and personal life are often <b>blurring</b> for remote workers."

Condemnation noun

The expression of very strong disapproval; censure.

Synonyms: Censure, Reproach, Denunciation

"The politician faced widespread <b>condemnation</b> for his controversial remarks."

Contemptuous adjective

Showing contempt; scornful.

Synonyms: Scornful, Disdainful, Derisive

"His <b>contemptuous</b> tone indicated his complete disregard for her opinion."

Critique noun

A detailed analysis and assessment of something, especially a literary, philosophical, or political theory.

Synonyms: Analysis, Appraisal, Evaluation

"The literary <b>critique</b> highlighted both the strengths and weaknesses of the novel."

Deterrent noun

A thing that discourages or is intended to discourage someone from doing something.

Synonyms: Discouragement, Hindrance, Obstacle

"The strict penalties serve as a powerful <b>deterrent</b> against illegal poaching."

Epithets noun

An adjective or descriptive phrase expressing a quality characteristic of the person or thing mentioned; a disparaging or abusive word or phrase.

Synonyms: Labels, Titles, Appellations

"The speech was marred by crude <b>epithets</b> directed at the opposition."

Exacerbated verb

Made a problem, bad situation, or negative feeling worse.

Synonyms: Aggravated, Worsened, Intensified

"His rude comments only <b>exacerbated</b> the already tense situation."

Exaggerated adjective

Represented as being larger, better, or worse than it really is.

Synonyms: Overstated, Hyperbolized, Inflated

"The reports of his wealth were greatly <b>exaggerated</b>."

Exemplifies verb

Is a typical example of.

Synonyms: Illustrates, Embodies, Personifies

"The success of the project <b>exemplifies</b> the power of teamwork."

Fostered verb

Encouraged or promoted the development of (something good).

Synonyms: Promoted, Encouraged, Nurtured

"The school aims to have <b>fostered</b> a love for learning in all its students."

Functionaries noun

A person who performs a particular office or duty; an official.

Synonyms: Officials, Bureaucrats, Civil servants

"Public <b>functionaries</b> are expected to uphold the highest standards of integrity."

Incendiary adjective

Tending to stir up conflict or provoke a strong reaction; inflammatory.

Synonyms: Inflammatory, Provocative, Agitating

"The politician's <b>incendiary</b> speech was met with widespread criticism."

Intolerance noun

Lack of acceptance of people, ideas, or actions different from one's own.

Synonyms: Bigotry, Prejudice, Discrimination

"The company has a zero-<b>intolerance</b> policy for harassment in the workplace."

Legitimate adjective

Conforming to laws or rules; able to be defended with logic or justification.

Synonyms: Valid, Lawful, Justifiable

"His claim to the property was entirely <b>legitimate</b>."

Manifest adjective

Clear or obvious to the eye or mind.

Synonyms: Obvious, Apparent, Evident

"Her joy was <b>manifest</b> in her bright smile and cheerful demeanor."

Marginalizing verb

Treating (a person, group, or concept) as insignificant or peripheral.

Synonyms: Excluding, Sidelining, Disregarding

"The new policy risks <b>marginalizing</b> small businesses in the market."

Perceptible adjective

Able to be seen or noticed; especially faint.

Synonyms: Noticeable, Discernible, Detectable

"There was a <b>perceptible</b> shift in the public's mood after the announcement."

Posture noun

A particular approach or attitude to something.

Synonyms: Stance, Attitude, Bearing

"The company adopted an aggressive <b>posture</b> in the competitive market."

Prerogative noun

A right or privilege exclusive to a particular individual or class.

Synonyms: Right, Privilege, Entitlement

"It is the manager's <b>prerogative</b> to decide who gets promoted."

Pronouncements noun

A formal or authoritative announcement or declaration.

Synonyms: Declarations, Statements, Edicts

"The President's recent <b>pronouncements</b> on economic policy were widely debated."

Retrogressive adjective

Returning to an earlier and inferior condition.

Synonyms: Regressive, Backward, Declining

"Many viewed the new education reforms as a <b>retrogressive</b> step for the country."

Reverse verb

To change to the contrary or opposite; to turn back.

Synonyms: Undo, Invert, Overturn

"The government decided to <b>reverse</b> its decision after public outcry."

Scrutiny noun

Critical observation or examination.

Synonyms: Examination, Inspection, Investigation

"The financial records were subjected to intense <b>scrutiny</b> by the auditors."

Subversion noun

The undermining of the power and authority of an established system or institution.

Synonyms: Overthrow, Destabilization, Undermining

"The government cracked down on any acts of political <b>subversion</b>."

Succumb verb

Fail to resist pressure, temptation, or some other negative force.

Synonyms: Yield, Give in, Give way

"Despite intense pressure, she refused to <b>succumb</b> to their demands."

Temperament noun

A person's or animal's nature, especially as it permanently affects their behavior.

Synonyms: Disposition, Nature, Character

"He has a calm and balanced <b>temperament</b>, making him suitable for leadership."

Unbecoming adjective

Not fitting or appropriate; unattractive.

Synonyms: Inappropriate, Unsuitable, Indecorous

"Such behavior is utterly <b>unbecoming</b> of a professional."

Undermine verb

Lessen the effectiveness, power, or ability of, especially gradually or insidiously.

Synonyms: Weaken, Erode, Subvert

"Constant criticism can <b>undermine</b> a child's confidence."

Variable adjective

Not consistent or having a fixed pattern; liable to change.

Synonyms: Fluctuating, Changeable, Inconsistent

"The weather in the mountains can be highly <b>variable</b>."

Warranted adjective

Justified or necessary.

Synonyms: Justified, Merited, Deserved

"The severe penalty was deemed <b>warranted</b> by the gravity of the crime."

Phrasal Verbs

make out

To discern or understand something, often with difficulty.

"It was hard to <i>make out</i> the judge's subtle distinction in his lengthy verdict."

cropped up

Appeared or occurred unexpectedly.

"New concerns about the policy have <i>cropped up</i> during the public debate."

brushing off

Dismissing something as unimportant or irrelevant.

"The committee was criticized for <i>brushing off</i> valid public complaints."

call into question

To cause doubts about something.

"The recent findings <i>call into question</i> the validity of the previous research."

put forth

To propose or present an idea, theory, or plan.

"The lawyer <i>put forth</i> a compelling argument in defense of his client."

succumb to

To yield to a superior force, pressure, or temptation.

"He refused to <i>succumb to</i> the intense pressure from the media."

PrepZen

Keep Learning with PrepZen

Get daily current affairs, live mock tests, mistake bank, vocab builder & more — all free on your phone.

Download Now — Free
PrepZen

Get PrepZen Free

Daily CA, Mock Tests & More

GET