PrepZen Daily Current Affairs & Exam Desk
Editorial · 2 min read · THE HINDU PAPER EDITORIAL

The Dubious Strategy Behind Great Nicobar's Development

Share: WhatsApp
The ambitious Great Nicobar Island development project, valued at a staggering

₹91,000 crore, faces significant scrutiny despite being repeatedly touted as a national security imperative . Initially, the project’s central component, a transshipment port at Galathea Bay, was shielded from detailed environmental disclosures under the guise of its strategic importance. However, a crucial assessment by the Public Investment Board (PIB) in August 2024 shockingly concluded that the port actually lacked defined strategic objectives. This 'strategic' designation appears to be a mere afterthought , hastily applied by the Ministry of Defence to rationalize its immense financial outlay . Further underscoring these concerns, the Public-Private Partnership Appraisal Committee (PPPAC) not only cleared the proposal but also delivered an uncommon rebuke by refusing ₹12,230 crore in Viability Gap Funding, directing the Ports Ministry to come up with the funds from its own budget. This raises serious questions: if the port is not commercially viable and its alleged military purpose is disputed , the commercial transshipment hub argument effectively dissolves . The project’s fundamental premise seems to fall apart under examination. It's difficult to make a case for such a massive undertaking without clear economic or strategic merit.Beyond the financial and strategic ambiguities , the ecological consequences are profound . Great Nicobar, a biodiversity hotspot, is home to pristine tropical rainforests and unique coral reefs. The proposed infrastructure – including an international airport, power plant, and township – necessitates clearing out extensive areas of primary forest, thereby endangering critical nesting sites for the leatherback turtle and the habitat of the endemic Nicobar megapode. Scientists caution that this environmental degradation would be irreversible , stressing that no compensatory afforestation could ever offset such an ecological loss. The island’s indigenous communities also harbor strong objections , asserting that their consent was obtained without full transparency and that their ancestral lands and promised resettlement (post-2004 tsunami) are being jeopardized . Their dissent is not against development per se, but rather against the project’s sheer magnitude , the prevailing secrecy, and the questionable implementation sequence . The imperative solution is full transparency: the Centre must publicly account for the true public cost, weighing it against the irreplaceable environmental devastation that no financial reimbursement can ever truly cover.

Get daily updates on PrepZen App

Free · 10,000+ downloads · 4.8★

Download

Vocabulary from this Editorial

Afforestation noun

The establishment of a forest or stand of trees in an area where there was no forest.

Synonyms: reforestation, tree planting, woodland creation

"The government launched a massive afforestation drive to combat desertification in the region."

Afterthought noun

An idea, plan, or explanation that is thought of or added later, often as an incidental or less important part.

Synonyms: supplement, addendum, postscript

"The strategic justification for the project seemed more of an afterthought than a founding principle."

Alleged adjective

Stated or asserted to be true without proof; supposed.

Synonyms: supposed, claimed, reported

"The alleged culprit maintained his innocence throughout the trial."

Ambiguities noun

Statements or situations that are open to more than one interpretation; inexactness.

Synonyms: uncertainties, vagueness, obscurities

"The contract was full of ambiguities, making it difficult to understand the exact terms."

Ambitious adjective

Having or showing a strong desire and determination to succeed; requiring great effort or skill.

Synonyms: aspiring, determined, challenging

"The company embarked on an ambitious plan to expand into new markets."

Ancestral adjective

Of, belonging to, or inherited from an ancestor or ancestors.

Synonyms: hereditary, inherited, traditional

"They visited their ancestral village to learn about their family roots."

Applied verb

Put into operation or practical use.

Synonyms: implemented, utilized, employed

"The new policies were successfully applied across all departments."

Asserting verb

Stating a fact or belief confidently and forcefully.

Synonyms: claiming, declaring, affirming

"The company is asserting its rights to the intellectual property."

Assessment noun

The evaluation or estimation of the nature, quality, or ability of someone or something.

Synonyms: evaluation, appraisal, judgment

"A thorough assessment of the damage was conducted after the storm."

Caution verb

Warn (someone) against danger or error.

Synonyms: warn, advise, exhort

"Experts caution against underestimating the potential risks of the new technology."

Compensatory adjective

Intended to recompense someone who has experienced loss, suffering, or injury.

Synonyms: reparative, reimbursing, indemnifying

"The court awarded compensatory damages to the victim for the financial losses incurred."

Concluded verb

Brought (something) to an end; finished.

Synonyms: finished, ended, completed

"The investigation concluded that there was no evidence of foul play."

Consequences noun

Results or effects of an action or condition.

Synonyms: outcomes, results, repercussions

"Ignoring environmental warnings can lead to severe ecological consequences."

Crucial adjective

Extremely important, because it will affect other things.

Synonyms: vital, critical, essential

"The decision made today will be crucial for the company's future."

Degradation noun

The process of being degraded, or the state of being degraded; a decline to a lower condition, quality, or level.

Synonyms: deterioration, decline, erosion

"Pollution is a major cause of environmental degradation."

Delivered verb

To produce, present, or hand over (something, such as a speech, verdict, or goods).

Synonyms: presented, issued, gave

"The jury delivered a unanimous verdict after hours of deliberation."

Designation noun

The action of choosing someone or something for a special purpose, or the formal title or description of someone or something.

Synonyms: appellation, title, label

"The city received a new designation as a UNESCO World Heritage site."

Directing verb

Controlling the operations or performance of something; instructing someone to do something.

Synonyms: guiding, managing, commanding

"The CEO is directing the company's new strategic initiatives."

Disclosures noun

The action of making new or secret information known.

Synonyms: revelations, uncoverings, exposures

"The financial disclosures revealed some concerning irregularities in their accounts."

Disputed verb

Argued about (something); contested.

Synonyms: contested, challenged, debated

"The boundary line between the two properties has been disputed for years."

Dissent noun

The expression or holding of opinions contrary to those previously, commonly, or officially expressed.

Synonyms: disagreement, opposition, protest

"There was considerable dissent among the committee members regarding the new policy."

Dissolves verb

Fades away or comes to an end; (of an idea or feeling) disappears.

Synonyms: vanishes, disappears, evaporates

"The illusion quickly dissolves when confronted with reality."

Endangering verb

Putting (someone or something) at risk or in danger.

Synonyms: jeopardizing, threatening, imperiling

"Pollution is endangering many species in the ecosystem."

Endemic adjective

(Of a disease or condition) regularly found among particular people or in a certain area; (of a plant or animal) native or restricted to a certain country or area.

Synonyms: native, indigenous, local

"The Tasmanian devil is an endemic species to Tasmania."

Extensive adjective

Covering or affecting a large area; large in amount or scale.

Synonyms: widespread, broad, vast

"The company conducted extensive research before launching the new product."

Fundamental adjective

Forming a necessary base or core; of central importance.

Synonyms: basic, essential, core

"Respect for human rights is a fundamental principle of democracy."

Guise noun

An external form, appearance, or manner of presentation, typically concealing the true nature of something.

Synonyms: pretense, disguise, cloak

"He approached them under the guise of an old friend."

Harbor verb

To keep a thought or feeling, typically a negative one, in one's mind for a long time.

Synonyms: cherish, nurture, foster

"She harbored doubts about the true intentions of the new employee."

Hastily adverb

With excessive speed or urgency; hurriedly.

Synonyms: hurriedly, quickly, rapidly

"He hastily packed his bags, fearing he would miss his flight."

Immense adjective

Extremely large or great, especially in scale or degree.

Synonyms: enormous, vast, huge

"The project required an immense amount of capital investment."

Imperative noun

An essential or urgent thing.

Synonyms: necessity, priority, command

"Addressing climate change is a moral imperative for humanity."

Implementation noun

The process of putting a decision or plan into effect; execution.

Synonyms: execution, application, enactment

"The implementation of the new software took several months."

Irreplaceable adjective

Impossible to replace if lost or damaged.

Synonyms: unique, invaluable, priceless

"The destruction of the ancient manuscript was an irreplaceable loss to history."

Irreversible adjective

Impossible to reverse or undo.

Synonyms: permanent, unalterable, unrecoverable

"The damage to the ozone layer could be irreversible."

Jeopardized verb

Put (someone or something) into a situation in which there is a danger of loss, harm, or failure.

Synonyms: endangered, threatened, imperiled

"His reckless actions jeopardized the entire mission."

Lacked verb

Was without or did not have (something).

Synonyms: missed, needed, wanted

"The old house lacked modern amenities."

Magnitude noun

The great size or extent of something.

Synonyms: scale, extent, size

"The magnitude of the earthquake was devastating."

Necessitates verb

Makes (something) necessary as a result or consequence.

Synonyms: requires, demands, entails

"The new policy necessitates a change in our operational procedures."

Objections noun

An expression or feeling of disapproval or opposition; a reason for disagreeing.

Synonyms: protests, reservations, disagreements

"Several committee members raised strong objections to the proposed changes."

Obtained verb

Got, acquired, or secured (something) through effort or by request.

Synonyms: acquired, gained, procured

"He obtained a scholarship to study abroad."

Offset verb

Counteract (something) by having an opposing force or effect.

Synonyms: balance, compensate, counterbalance

"The extra revenue helped to offset the unexpected expenses."

Outlay noun

An amount of money spent on something.

Synonyms: expenditure, expense, cost

"The initial outlay for the new factory was considerable."

Premise noun

A previous statement or proposition from which another is inferred or follows as a conclusion.

Synonyms: assumption, hypothesis, presumption

"The entire argument was based on a faulty premise."

Pristine adjective

In its original condition; unspoiled; clean and fresh as if new.

Synonyms: unspoiled, immaculate, spotless

"The pristine beaches of the island attracted many tourists."

Profound adjective

Very great or intense; (of a state, quality, or emotion) very great or intense.

Synonyms: deep, intense, extreme

"The experience had a profound effect on his life."

Questionable adjective

Doubtful as regards truth, authenticity, or quality.

Synonyms: dubious, suspicious, doubtful

"His ethical practices at work have always been questionable."

Rationalize verb

Attempt to explain or justify (behavior or an attitude) with plausible reasons, even if these are not true or appropriate.

Synonyms: justify, excuse, explain

"He tried to rationalize his decision, but it was clear he had made a mistake."

Rebuke noun

An expression of sharp disapproval or criticism.

Synonyms: reprimand, reproach, censure

"The committee issued a strong rebuke to the minister for his irresponsible statements."

Reimbursement noun

The action of repaying a person who has spent or lost money.

Synonyms: repayment, compensation, indemnification

"Employees can claim reimbursement for travel expenses."

Scrutiny noun

Critical observation or examination.

Synonyms: inspection, examination, analysis

"The company's finances came under intense scrutiny after the scandal."

Secure verb

Obtain (something), especially after a great deal of effort.

Synonyms: obtain, acquire, procure

"It took months of negotiations to secure the funding for the project."

Sequence noun

A particular order in which related things follow each other.

Synonyms: order, succession, arrangement

"The events occurred in a precise sequence."

Sheer adjective

Nothing other than; unmitigated (used for emphasis).

Synonyms: utter, absolute, complete

"The sheer size of the mountain was awe-inspiring."

Shielded verb

Protected (someone or something) from something dangerous or unpleasant.

Synonyms: protected, guarded, sheltered

"The data was shielded from unauthorized access by strong encryption."

Transparency noun

The condition of being transparent; openness and accountability in business practices.

Synonyms: openness, clarity, frankness

"The government promised greater transparency in its financial dealings."

Uncommon adjective

Not happening or found frequently or typically; unusual.

Synonyms: unusual, rare, infrequent

"It is not uncommon for students to feel nervous before exams."

Underscoring verb

Emphasizing the importance of something.

Synonyms: emphasizing, highlighting, stressing

"The report is underscoring the urgent need for reform."

Viable adjective

Capable of working successfully; feasible.

Synonyms: feasible, workable, achievable

"The startup presented a viable business model to the investors."

Phrasal Verbs

touted as

Presented or advertised as being something particular, often with exaggerated praise.

"The new smartphone was touted as a revolutionary device."

come up with

To think of an idea, plan, or solution; to produce or find something.

"We need to come up with a better strategy for marketing."

fall apart

To break into pieces; to fail or cease to function successfully.

"After several disagreements, their partnership started to fall apart."

make a case for

To argue that something is the best thing to do, giving your reasons.

"She made a strong case for investing in renewable energy."

clearing out

To remove unwanted items from a place; to empty a place of its contents.

"The family spent the weekend clearing out the old attic."

account for

To explain the reason for something; to give a reckoning of money received or spent.

"The suspect could not account for his whereabouts on the night of the crime."

PrepZen

Keep Learning with PrepZen

Get daily current affairs, live mock tests, mistake bank, vocab builder & more — all free on your phone.

Download Now — Free
PrepZen

Get PrepZen Free

Daily CA, Mock Tests & More

GET